| Name | School | Division | |
| 2006 & Before | |||
| Andrea Gammon | Maryville College | NCAA DII | |
| Laura Newcomb | Murray State | NCAA DI | |
| Laurie Cheek | Greenville College | NCAA DIII | |
| Nikki Smith | Jackson State | NCAA DI | |
| Monica WIlliams | Park College | NAIA | |
| Antoinette Anderson | College of the Ozarks | NAIA | |
| Angel Anderson | Southwest Baptist | NCAA DII | |
| Paula Rodgers | Livingston University | NAIA | |
| Brenda Rucks | Lemony-Owen | NCAA DII | |
| Amanda Herbert | Arkansas State University | NCAA DI | |
| Christian Netherland | Missouri Baptist | NAIA | |
| Brooke Johnson | Missouri Baptist | NAIA | |
| Casey Glass | Williams Baptist | NAIA | |
| Chiquita Pullen | Missouri Baptist | NAIA | |
| Summer Field | Williams Baptist | NAIA | |
| Christy Johnson | Williams Baptist | NAIA | |
| Brandi Mallonee | Hannable-Lagrange | NAIA | |
| Laura Chilton | Williams Baptist | NAIA | |
| Paula Corder | Southeast Missouri State | NCAA DI | |
| Tanisha Albert | University of Missouri - St. Louis | NCAA DII | |
| Latasha Thompson | Texas Southern | NCAA D1 | |
| Holly Teague | Southern Illinois | NCAA DI | |
| Lacey Shelton | Evangel | NAIA | |
| Beth Schnakenberg | Murray State University | NCAA DI | |
| Tierra Wright | University of Missouri - St Louis | NCAA DII | |
| Michelle Gainey | Southeast Louisiana University | NCAA D1 | |
| Erika Emmons | Williams Baptist | NAIA | |
| Ashley Barnes | Missouri Baptist | NAIA | |
| Sara Heisseier | Williams Baptist | NAIA | |
| Victoria Richards | University of Central Missouri | NCAA DII | |
| Nicole Rivers | UT Martin | NCAA DI | |
| Jess Wilson | UT Martin/Columbia College | NCAA D1/NAIA | |
| Liz McCrackin | Williams Baptist College | NAIA | |
| Emmerentia Ledwaba | University of Mobile | NAIA | |
| April Redus | Missouri Baptist | NAIA | |
| Omega Key | Mid Continent University | NAIA | |
| Megan Brown | Missouri Baptist | NAIA | |
| Missy Whitney | Southeast Missouri State | NCAA DI | |
| Amanda Lance | McKendree | NCAA DII | |
| 2006-2007 | |||
| Tierra Johnson | Southeast Missouri State | NCAA DI | |
| 2008-2009 | |||
| Danisha Mitchell | Harris Stowe | NAIA | |
| Brittany Peet | Williams Baptist | NAIA | |
| Fareedah Washington | Missouri S&T | NCAA DII | |
| 2009-2010 | |||
| Chelsey Johnson | Troy, then Georgetown College | NCAA D1/NAIA | |
| Sara Woodgeard | Missouri Baptist | NAIA | |
| 2010-2011 | |||
| Ashley Taylor | Williams Woods | NAIA | |
| Jill Temples | Henderson State | NCAA DII | |
| 2011-2012 | |||
| Brooke Godsey | Columbia College | NAIA | |
| Whitney Mills | Williams Baptist | NAIA | |
| 2012-2013 | |||
| Andrea Becker | |||
| Moriah Goodrum | |||
| Alex Hower | |||
| Carolyn Overton | |||
| Tara Porter | |||
| Dennisha Rice | William Woods | NAIA | |
| Monae Riley | Lindenwood-Belleville | NAIA | |
| Tameka Scott | |||
| 2013-2014 | |||
| Erin Bollmann | Southeast Missouri State | NCAA DI | |
| Kamryn Hutsell | |||
| Antonia Lee | |||
| Cassie Roberts | |||
| Anna Vogt | Coastal Carolina | NCAA DI | |
| Marissa Webb | Williams Woods | NAIA | |
| Whitney Welker | |||
| Macy Wright | |||
| 2014-2015 | |||
| Aaryana Cook | Missouri Baptist | NAIA | |
| Cierra Cawvey | |||
| Tori Cole | |||
| Ericka Engelman | |||
| Danielle Farmer | |||
| Alytrius Perry | Williams Baptist | NAIA | |
| Andrea Sullivan | |||
| 2015-2016 | |||
| Samantha Gatewood | |||
| Chelsea Vinson | Lincoln University | NCAA DII | |
| 2016-2017 | |||
| Michael Everhart | West Virginia State | NCAA DII | |
| Kaylee Heggemann | Webster University | NCAA DIII | |
| Jay Perry | Williams Baptist | NAIA | |
| Ge'Naisha Robinson | Young Harris College / Bethel University | NCAA DII / NAIA | |
| Jalisa Smith | Eastern Kentucky | NCAA DI | |
| Joya Smith | Eastern Kentucky | NCAA DI | |
| Destiney Williams | Martin Methodist | NAIA | |
| 2017-2018 | |||
| D'Nayia Holmes | Elizabeth City State University | NCAA DII | |
| Alex Kohler | Loyola University - New Orleans | NAIA | |
| Markeia Porter | Elizabeth City State University | NCAA DII | |
| 2018-2019 | |||
| Hailee Erickson | Arkansas State University | NCAA DI | |
| Kimberley Shaw | Missouri Baptist University | NAIA | |
| 2019-2020 | |||
| Brogan Jones | Central Baptist College | NAIA | |
| Jordan Little | Union University | NCAA DII | |
| An'Nyah Pettus | Southwest Baptist University | NCAA DII | |
| Hannah Thurmon | University of Montana | NCAA DI | |
| Deanay Watson | Southeast Missouri State | NCAA DI | |
| 2020-2021 | |||
| Hya Haywood | Lincoln University | NCAA DII | |
| Cameran Martin | College of the Ozarks | NCCAA | |
| 2021-2022 | |||
| Myia Yelder | Utah State University | NCAA DI | |
| Joi Montgomery | Stetson University | NCAA DI | |
| Autumn Dodd | Old Dominion University | NCAA DI | |
| Jamiyah Thomas | California Univeristy of Pennsylvania | NCAA DII | |
| Kourtney Kendrick | William Woods | NAIA | |
| Karlee Holland | Baptist Bible College | NCCAA | |